Straight to the Bar

All Things Strength


What Weight Training Can NOT Do For You
Written By : Girlwith Noname
Filed In : Articles
Girlwith Noname

Girlwith Noname.

When I frequent my gym, I never go into the ladies area. I find it just a bit TOO ‘lady-like‘ with its little pink dumbbells and petite machines designed for light lifting, not to mention the ubiquitous and ridiculous ‘hip toner‘ machine.

When I visited my gym a couple of days ago, out of curiousity I wandered through the ladies area just to see if anything had changed in there lately. Sadly, I discovered that nothing has changed since I wandered through there a few years ago. They still have the tiny dumbbells and there was that ‘hip toner‘ machine STILL!!! It is this machine in particular that got me thinking about what strength training / weight training can and cannot do for you, me and everyone else!
That ‘hip toner‘ machine reminds me of a huge misperception out there in the world of fitness that a lot of people have about “Spot Reducing“.
First of all, let me tell you flat out: SPOT REDUCING IS A MYTH! If you have extra fat on your hips, doing a million reps on that ‘hip toner‘ machine will NEVER reduce the fat on your hips. If you have excess flab on your abs, you can do a TRILLION crunches, sit-ups and leg lifts but it will never reduce the fat on your abdominal area. What it WILL do is build up the muscle under the fat in those areas. Therefore, you are actually working towards making an area you are trying to reduce BIGGER!! This is completely counterintuitive to your goal of reduction.

In order to reduce fat in any particular area of your body, please understand that you must lose fat OVERALL on your body. Fat loss is a global thing, either you lose it everywhere or you lose it nowhere. It will never melt off in one area only just because you are working the muscle under that fat to death. So, if you want to reduce fat, prepare to have it come off all over your body, not just in the area you most desire. In order to lose those larger hips or flabby abs, put yourself on a conditioning program designed to burn fat (ie. cardio or HIT) and also get yourself on an eating program that puts you into a calorie deficit (meaning you burn more calories each day than you consume).
Please don’t misunderstand what I’m saying here though. If you are looking to lose fat, you should definitely continue to weight train, for several reasons. One important reason is that once you do lose the fat you will have a more toned and fit appearance with the better muscle definition that weight training will give you. Another important reason is that lean muscle burns more calories than fat all the time (which in turn will make your ability to burn fat, even at rest, much easier).
So, please never kid yourself that you can replace your fat with muscle in any particular area of your body or ‘spot reduce‘ the fat in one area only by weight training. It just doesn’t work that way.

Over to you. Drop us a line on Twitter ( @scottbird ), or add a comment below.



NB : if you love talking about strength-training as much as I do, you might also like to check out the weekly newsletter (there's also a daily version available). A regular dose of fitness-focussed discussions, absolutely free.


Leave a Reply

What's This?

Straight to the Bar is the online home of fitness enthusiast Scott Bird, and looks at the many training approaches, essential techniques, uncommon exercises and superb equipment to help you become as strong as humanly possible. In short, this site is the home of all things strength.

images of strength

'Napalm' Jedd Johnson.
Want to see (and learn) more Feats of Strength like this? Dive in.

Just Joined Us? Try These.

There are some incredible writers on the team here. To give you an idea, check these out :

If you enjoyed these, check out the complete ‘Best Of Straight to the Bar‘ list. Fantastic.

setting up a home gym?

If you’re getting ready to put together a solid Home Gym (fantastic thing), here’s how.

For more, swing by the full guide. Absolutely free.

And of course, you’ll find everything you need over in the SttB Strength Store. Massive range.

Ever Tried Kettlebells?

If you’ve seen people using them but never taken the plunge yourself, here are the ones I use personally. You can also pick up a book/DVD/course if you want to learn how to put them to work.

Ready To Learn Even More?

I love learning new skills, and the many seminars & workshops available are a great way to do that. If you’re looking for a specific type of workshop nearby, check out the ones on Dragon Door. Great mix of kettlebell and calisthenics-based offerings.

The Precision Nutrition Certification Program

The Precision Nutrition Certification Program

The Precision Nutrition Certification Program.

If you’re a fitness professional and love the Precision Nutrition approach, check out their certification offering. To say it’s comprehensive is an understatement.

Wherever You Are, We Are.

In addition to the main site, you can share your strength-training passion with a like-minded community on :

Wherever you like to hang out, get your regular dose of strength. Straight to the Bar.

Written By Girlwith Noname
Jackie Burgmann is a Personal Trainer, confirmed fitness junkie, and author of the ebook 'Hot at Home'. Find out more over on her blog, Twitter account and Facebook page.
Drawing of Scott Andrew Bird performing a deadlift. Artwork by Vince Palko.