Straight to the Bar

All Things Strength


Progressing to the Regression
Filed In : Articles | featured

Everyone wants to snatch. When that kettlebell comes out of the box, if you have even a passing familiarity with the movement odds are good that thing is getting snatched.

While everyone wants to snatch, not everyone wants to learn how to snatch. Fewer people want to learn how to swing. Brett Jones Master RKC stated “There is a big difference between swinging a kettlebell, and performing a kettlebell swing.” Perfectly put. Everyone is more than happy to swing kettlebells around, but not quite as quick to do all the drills necessary to learn how to perform a kettlebell swing.

In my workshops I work with personal trainers who want to add some kettlebell skills to their repertoire. Most often this works out fine and the trainers learn how to effectively perform the six core lifts of hard-style kettlebell training. On occasion I run into trainers who are unable to swallow their pride, and deal with the fact that most of what they know simply does not apply to kettlebell training. In fact, often trainers pretty much need to go back to square one and start the learning process all over again. Some cannot cope with this and don’t use kettlebells themselves. This is unfortunate as often the trainer will also be unable to swallow his pride when it comes to regressing a client.

There is a reason that the RKC program minimum is composed of the Turkish Get Up and the Swing. These two movements are the roots from which all other movements sprout. Swings, cleans, high pulls, snatches, all look pretty much the same from the hips down. If someone is unable to properly perform a swing, how are they going to perform a snatch, which is basically a more advanced swing?
 If I watch someone snatching and their hips lack any real snap, I know that if I watch their swings, the swings will be faulty as well. If they are ‘stiff arming‘ the snatch, I know their high pull is broken.

On occasion I will have a new client come in who has been doing kettlebells on his own for a while, and declares that he just needs some ‘fine tuning‘. Most often my definition of ‘fine tuning‘ means fine tuning the swing for hundreds of repetitions before I clear you to start snatching again.

It is not the fault of the client, as he is ensconced in a culture of snatch-happy Gireviks. Let’s face it; ripping out a crazy number of snatches just looks more impressive than a large number of swings. Is it more effective? Perhaps, but that is dependent upon the elevation of the technique utilized. 100 perfect swings will beat 1000 jacked up snatches every time. Those swings will also save you a few injuries.

So now is the time to be honest with yourself. How does your snatch form look? Is it far from perfect? Is it in fact flawed? If the answer is ‘yes‘, stop training Max VO2 and try to do a SSST immediately.

Go back and root out the fundamental flaws that are limiting your progress. Sometimes the snatch can be fixed without regressing, but since many problems can be fixed by going back to swings and get ups, why not?

Endlessly trying to snatch in hopes your form will correct itself, well… that actually does work. However, it takes much longer than correcting your cracked foundation. Once you have established a strong foundation, proceed to do thousands of snatches.

There is a very good reason that we do a Max VO2 snatch workout during the RKC certification. By then you have refined your snatch form, and performing many, many snatches will further refine it.

Run yourself through the checklist below. If you have one of the stated deviations, proceed to the solution, or to put it better ‘progress to the regression‘.

  • Is your wrist hyper-extended at lockout?- Get Ups.
  • Do your hips lack the snap required to propel the bell effortlessly up?- Swings.
  • Do you have a posterior pelvic tilt at lockout?- Get Ups.
  • Are you unstable at the top?- Swings and Get Ups.
  • Do you lack tension at the moment of execution? Swings.
  • Is your shoulder disconnected at lockout?- Get Ups.

So you’re most likely starting to get the message here. If you have any questions regarding the necessity of hammering on the basics so hard, refer to the quote below from Pavel Tsatsouline’s ‘Enter The Kettlebell‘.

The only thing that separates the elite from all the rest is the fact that the elite are better at the basics than everyone else.
Master Sergeant Duane Stanton, USAF Pararecsue

Over to you. Drop us a line on Twitter ( @scottbird ), or add a comment below.



NB : if you love talking about strength-training as much as I do, you might also like to check out the weekly newsletter. A regular dose of fitness-focussed discussions, absolutely free.

And if you'd like to check out any of the stuff mentioned above (or in the comments), swing by Amazon. Huge assortment of fitness gear.


Leave a Reply

What's This?

Straight to the Bar is the online home of fitness enthusiast Scott Bird, and looks at the many training approaches, essential techniques, uncommon exercises and superb equipment to help you become as strong as humanly possible. In short, this site is the home of all things strength.

images of strength

'Napalm' Jedd Johnson.
Want to see (and learn) more Feats of Strength like this? Dive in.

Just Joined Us? Try These.

There are some incredible writers on the team here. To give you an idea, check these out :

If you enjoyed these, check out the complete ‘Best Of Straight to the Bar‘ list. Fantastic.

setting up a home gym?

If you’re getting ready to put together a solid Home Gym (fantastic thing), here’s how.

For more, swing by the full guide. Absolutely free.

And of course, you’ll find everything you need over in the SttB Strength Store. Massive range.

Ever Tried Kettlebells?

If you’ve seen people using them but never taken the plunge yourself, here are the ones I use personally. You can also pick up a book/DVD/course if you want to learn how to put them to work.

Ready To Learn Even More?

I love learning new skills, and the many seminars & workshops available are a great way to do that. If you’re looking for a specific type of workshop nearby, check out the ones on Dragon Door. Great mix of kettlebell and calisthenics-based offerings.

The Precision Nutrition Certification Program

The Precision Nutrition Certification Program

The Precision Nutrition Certification Program.

If you’re a fitness professional and love the Precision Nutrition approach, check out their certification offering. To say it’s comprehensive is an understatement.

Wherever You Are, We Are.

In addition to the main site, you can share your strength-training passion with a like-minded community on :

Wherever you like to hang out, get your regular dose of strength. Straight to the Bar.

Jordan Vezina is a strength trainer in Palo Alto, CA and maintains a site at He enjoys Fat Tire Ale, and thinks you will too.
Drawing of Scott Andrew Bird performing a deadlift. Artwork by Vince Palko.